Jun 21, 2023Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem: ContentModerationatScaleIsImpossibletoDoWell. Mike Masnick, back in 2019: I've argued for years that while many people like to say that contentmoderationis difficult, that's misleading.Contentmoderationatscaleisimpossibletodowell.Importantly, this is not an argument that we should throw up our hands and do nothing.
This is maybe a logical extension of the author's "theorem:" part of maintaining good content-moderationis limiting the scale. Of course this is dicey because the most well-intentioned efforts to keep a forum/community "high-quality" can easily become exclusionary and/or elitist.
Feb 6, 2024I've talked about Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem over the years, that contentmoderationisimpossibletodowellatscale, and that applies to child safety material as well.
For a variety of reasons I've been studying the larger issues around contentmoderation. Mike Masnick offers Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem: ContentModerationAtScaleIsImpossibleToDoWell. It isn't that long, but it's important and his argument is powerful. He's not arguing for giving up on moderation, either.
And thus, throwing humility to the wind, I'd like to propose Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem, as a sort of play on Arrow's ImpossibilityTheorem. Contentmoderationatscaleisimpossibletodowell. More specifically, it will always end up frustrating very large segments of the population and will always fail to accurately represent the ...
But as Mike Masnick puts it in his self-anointed Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem, "contentmoderationatscaleis ... like contentmoderation, isimpossibletodowellat scale—it is a nuanced task that is highly contextual, and thus requires a correspondingly nuanced structure of distributed processing and control to be done well ...
There is an underlying technology problem here, not merely a social one. On some level, the scale itself could be identified as the culprit; Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem contends that contentmoderationatscaleisimpossibletodowell.
Jun 22, 2023Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem: ContentModerationAtScaleIsImpossibleToDoWell. 🔗 a linked post to techdirt.com » — originally shared here on 2023-06-22 More specifically, it will always end up frustrating very large segments of the population and will always fail to accurately represent the "proper" level of moderation of anyone.
FT reporter Hannah Murphy later tweeted that Bosworth was citing Masnick'sImpossibilityTheorem: a maxim, coined by Techdirt founder Mike Masnick, that says "contentmoderationatscaleis ...
Can’t find what you’re looking for?
Help us improve DuckDuckGo searches with your feedback